Tuesday, February 23, 2010

Roses in Bags ... The Sequel

After I had some time to digest my rant from yesterday about abused roses in bags being sold to unsuspecting customers, I realized that I left out something really, really important ....

If the roses I showed at Big Lots are poor examples, what do good bare root roses look like?

I'll show you some photos so you can see for yourself.

Here are two bagged roses, bought from Home Depot last year.  The Grade #1 on the label means that each rose has 3 or more good-sized canes.  The grade designation has nothing to do with the health or condition of the rose.

This is what the roses looked like when I removed them from the package:

See how most of the roots had to be chopped off so the rose would fit into the colorful little plastic bag?

This is what a bare root rose is supposed to look like:

Healthy canes ... profuse roots ... this rose is beautiful.

Here was my entire order before I tied it.  12 roses, carefully bundled and wrapped in a large plastic bag so they wouldn't dry out.  What a contrast!

In the interest of full disclosure, I have to tell you that the bagged roses and the Canadian roses are budded onto different rootstocks. 

The bagged roses are on Dr. Huey, the most prevalent rootstock out there, which grows well in the rose production fields in Texas and California, but is lousy in the acid, clay soil here in Virginia.  You all would recognize Dr. Huey ...  he's that dark red, once blooming rose that you get when your rose's graft dies?  (I once heard it called the most popular rose in America ... and not in a good way.)

The other roses are budded onto Rosa multiflora, which is much better suited for my area.  It has a finer root structure, which is why the photos above look like a rats nest.

If you're want to buy budded roses, I highly recommend the following Canadian nurseries.  There's no problem shipping to the US, their prices are very reasonable, customer service is good, and I've already shown you the quality you can expect to receive.

Palatine Roses

Pickering Nursery

Got Questions?  I'll be happy to answer them.

(written by Hartwood Roses.  Hartwood Roses blog.)


  1. Living in MI I have learned that roses grown on their own roots suited to our cold winters are the best. Dr. Buck roses and Canadian Explorers are my preference.

  2. Most of the budded roses I grow are ones that that I could not buy on their own roots. Now that I have them, I take cuttings and make own-root babies from them. I have others that are newer roses that I cannot legally progagate, that were given to me by friends. Own-root is my preference ... for many reasons. Hey, sounds like the subject of a blog post. :)


Thanks for stopping by and reading what I share. Comments are welcome and very much appreciated. Spam and trolls are not!

Related Posts with Thumbnails